Archive for the ‘the practice of medicine’ Category

Moving Toward an Accountable Care Organization (ACO): The Healthcare World is Changing, Are You?

Wednesday, September 8th, 2010

Yesterday, CIGNA announced the launch of an accountable care organization (ACO) pilot with the Piedmont Physicians Group in Atlanta, Georgia.  The essential intention behind this pilot is to demonstrate how primary care physicians can be rewarded for improving outcomes while also having lower medical costs.

The pilot program will monitor and coordinate ALL aspects of patient care. Patients will not have to do or change anything in this pilot.  All of the adjustments will be done internally.  Patients will most likely experience immediate benefits in the management of chronic conditions, such as diabetes.

The CIGNA/ Piedmont pilot uses a registered nurse as the clinical care coordinator.  This role is specifically oriented to assist patients as they navigate through the healthcare system to manage their health issues.  The care coordinator adds an additional layer of interface that will use data and clinical programs to help support the individual’s needs.  The focus will be on improved outcomes.

In essence, this program, and others like it, are going back to basics on one level and moving forward on another.  The focus will be on prevention – keep an individual well but once the individual needs to access care, the pilot will work to coordinate that care, guiding the patient through the process with knowledge and informing data.

CIGNA will continue to pay the primary care physicians for the medical services they provide but they will also pay a care coordination fee along with a possible reward in a pay for performance structure.  In some ways, this is similar to concierge practices where the physician continues to provide medical services for reimbursement from third party payers but also collects an annual fee for additional services – services not unlike care coordination and an emphasis on prevention.  The responsibility for that additional fee becomes the payer’s in exchange for improved outcomes.  Sounds like a win-win situation.

Providers need to make way for new incentive programs like this one.  Whether a hospital or a physician organization, preparation for change needs to happen now.  There is substantial information flowing about electronic health records (EHRs), utilization of outcomes data and comparative effectiveness research findings and the ability to provide care coordination.  It is likely that these three tenants will form the basis of a provider’s ability to become an ACO.

The handwriting on the wall indicates that providers will be paid for keeping patients healthy.  Providers should reconsider the value of their outreach programs that seek to motivate physical activity, healthier diets and smoking cessation.  Some early research (Trust for American’s Health, 2008) suggests that funds spent on prevention outreach lead to significant savings in healthcare costs.  This kind of outreach is already in place in many organizations.  If not, the easiest step is to focus on wellness events and early detection programs and begin planning for the other steps (EHR implementation, using comparative effectiveness research findings and coordination of care).  The world is changing and providers need to change along with these new (or renewed) constructs.

  • Blogger Post
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Digg
Subscribe

The Value of Time-out

Wednesday, September 1st, 2010

You might have noticed that I took most of the summer off from writing.  I could blame it on having two hospitalizations for close family members (while those events served as good market research opportunities, it is good to report that both family members are doing just fine now!) but really…I wanted to spend more time just thinking.

We move too fast in our technologically enhanced world.  With our Blackberries in hand, we can check our emails even while vacationing in the mountains.  Or, if email is too slow and phone calls too cumbersome — fear not — we can text, tweet or just move on without completing the communication loop.

A friend of mine thinks it is just the glamour of new technology that pushes us to unfettered limits.  I am not so sure.  Somehow we have to make decisions about the depth of our thoughtfulness and if we are pressed to answer in a nano-second and move onto the next issue, are we even making good decisions?

I am a baby-boomer by demographic profile, so I know what life was like before we could wake up to our email worrying about what we missed in the night.  Isn’t it important for us to help the younger generations keep what is good as we advance?  Isn’t thoughtful consideration, a time hungry endeavor, worthy of our need to hold on to it?

If you agree that you are spinning too fast whether you are at work or can’t relax while on vacation, it is time to speak up.  We need to push for the productivity of thinking.  We need to remember that good decisions about our work are borne out of planning and considering – not check-offs for tasks that get done.  Let’s take another look at that phrase, less is more.

And while we are pulling back to reflect when the need arises, should we, as those who dwell in health care delivery, also spend some time thinking about how we can do our work better?  Is more specialization the answer?  Should we be alarmed when an urologist tells us that he “only focuses on the plumbing” and if we want to know about the impact on Coumadin on radiation cystitis, we better seek out the cardiologist.  Yes, I understand what he meant but isn’t my father impacted by both his bladder and his heart?  Does the coordination then fall to the patient?  In this case an 81 year-old without any clinical awareness?

Okay, this has been the summer of thought.  And, my intent is to continue with this blog as an instructive device but also one that includes thinking fodder to push us and stretch us to do more than get stuff done but to get it done well as game-changing momentum.

Onward!

  • Blogger Post
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Digg
Subscribe

Thinking Fodder for Healthcare Reform

Tuesday, February 23rd, 2010

Okay, I am still thinking about healthcare reform.  I hope you are as well because we need the workers and thinkers who dwell in the healthcare arena to speak up and speak out.  We need to be the problem solvers.  Later this week, President Obama and members of Congress will gather to discuss solutions.  It is important for us to stay tuned but we have much work in front of us, no matter what.

Periodically, I will gather thinkers or information and report on different perspectives to provide fodder for the rest of us to consider, mull and hopefully discuss.  I just heard an interview with the CEO at Cleveland Clinic, Toby Cosgrove, M.D. Check out the link but I have also included some key bullet points below – in most cases, the bullet points below are direct quotes from the interview posted on Fortune, February 17, 2010, on CNN/Money:

  • We do not have a system of health-care delivery in the U.S. It’s a series of mom-and-pop shops all over the country, and it has not been systematized.
  • So regardless of what happens [with reform], we can really only try to contain the rate of inflation. The cost is going to go up over time.

Cost drivers?  Areas to seek improvement?

  • Let’s take obesity [as a health concern and cost driver.] It accounts for 10% of the cost of health care in the U.S. — we will never be able to control the cost of health care until we begin to control the epidemic of obesity. Two-thirds of the U.S. is overweight, and one-third is obese. We are the fattest nation in the world.
  • [When considering preventive measures for employees,] it’s always been a question of “What’s the ROI on this?” Until very recently, people didn’t realize the ROI is probably 3 to 1: For every dollar invested, you get three back in terms of employees being better.
  • Three things — smoking, diet, and lack of exercise — cause 40% of premature deaths in the U.S. They contribute to 70% of the chronic diseases, things like emphysema and heart disease. And that’s 75% of the cost of health care. It’s huge!

How Cleveland Clinic is different:

  • Very few hospitals are organized the way we are. First, all of us have salaries. It doesn’t make any difference, if I’m a cardiac surgeon, whether I do two heart operations a day or four. I take home the same amount of money at the end of the week. So there’s no incentive to do extra tests or any of that.
  • Second, we all have one-year contracts, and we have annual professional reviews. So the quality of the doctors is controlled, there’s no tenure, and if you don’t make it, you don’t get a pay raise or you may not stay. That is one of the most important things we do. It’s quite different from most places, where doctors can practice for as long as they want to practice.
  • We are physician-led, which is quite different from most medical organizations…

How will hospitals change?

  • There are a lot of very successful for-profit hospitals. I think what we’re going to see is a roll-up of hospitals. I don’t think it’s reasonable anymore to think that each hospital can be independent — have its own financial support, its own purchasing, its own back office. You need efficiency.
  • We have an electronic thing called MyChart, where you can go on the Internet and read your record. Few other hospitals around the country have done it. But we think it’s the patients’ information. It’s about them. We’re working for them. Why shouldn’t they have the data?

Here is the link to CEO of Cleveland Clinic interview once more…it is worth reading Dr. Cosgrove’s thoughts and the interview is well done.  Keep the conversation going!


  • Blogger Post
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Digg
Subscribe

Creating Relationship Value through the Patient Experience (Part 3 of 5)

Thursday, January 21st, 2010

How high have you set the bar of satisfaction for the patient experience?  Here are what some other healthcare organizations are saying on their websites, this January (2010) about their view of the patient experience:

Cleveland Clinic

“Patients are the purpose of our work, and Cleveland Clinic has embarked on an ambitious plan to examine and improve every facet of the patient experience. This effort encompasses every point of contact between patient and provider, from parking to prescription pick up.”

Johns Hopkins Health System

“Our quest for excellence isn’t limited to the treatments we provide. Several initiatives are under way at Hopkins to help physicians, nurses and staff to deliver the best possible service to customers.”

Gettysburg Hospital

“Gettysburg Hospital is ramping up its commitment to patient satisfaction with the aid of a qualified specialist. Tracy Lee joined the hospital last September as director of patient experience. Lee tracks patient satisfaction survey results and develops strategies for improvement.

Lee explained that many health systems have placed renewed emphasis on patient satisfaction in recent years.  A federally mandated consumer survey known as HCAHPS—the results of which are available to the public—has driven that trend.

“We all know what it’s like to either be a patient or have a loved one in crisis, and I enjoy helping make that experience a better one,” she said.”


These three organizations could not be more different from one another. And yet is placing special emphasis on the patient experience.  Each of them are defining that experience as beyond taking care of a patient clinically:

  • “…every point of contact between patient and provider.”
  • “Excellence isn’t limited to treatments we provide.”

When a patient visits the hospital or a doctor’s office, that individual experiences a series of events that often overshadow the actual contact with the medical provider. On a recent medical visit , I spent 15 minutes with the physician and 45 minutes “in process” once I entered the office – time at reception, time in the waiting room, time with the med technologist, time waiting in the exam room and time checking out after the visit.  It is easy to see how a good interaction with the physician can be overtaken by less than stellar service interactions.

You have heard me say that service is the marketing and that phrase is so true when it comes to the patient experience.  If you patient leaves happy, they will consider the experience positive and likely share that with their friends and family.  They will probably want to be your patient for a long time and will refer others to you. Their positive experience will create a long-lasting relationship value for them.  If your patient leaves grumpy, none of these good things happen.  In fact, a patient is more likely to share bad service news than good news and in telling their friends and family, you are on your way to a poor reputation.

So, think about, how high is your patient experience bar?


  • Blogger Post
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Digg
Subscribe

Compassionate Caring

Monday, December 7th, 2009

Compassionate caring because it matters: listening to those who care and thankful for their teaching voices…

Snow has fallen, holiday lights twinkle and the bustle of the holidays are upon us.  I am thankful for today – a Monday – so I can catch up with myself.  The weekend was too busy!  Too much rushing; too much doing – a lot like each day. Perhaps this holiday season, it won’t just be about the “doing” but a lot more about the “being” and maybe understanding more about “others” and how our actions make a difference in the lives of those others.

So, as a departure from the routine and thanks to Paul Levy’s blog, Running a Hospital, I share this touching acceptance speech by Amy Ship, M.D., a primary care physician, as she is awarded this year’s Compassionate Caregiver Award by the Kenneth B. Schwartz Center. It is an elegant speech full of grace and humanity.  No matter where we are on the healthcare delivery continuum, it is good to consider, “the power of the smallest gesture” and to recognize that there is “no billing code for compassion.”  Thank you, Dr. Ship, for the caring that you exemplify and the teaching that you do.

Below is the Raymond Carver poem that she references and quotes in her speech:

What the Doctor Said

He said it doesn’t look good
he said it looks bad in fact real bad
he said I counted thirty-two of them on one lung before
I quit counting them
I said I’m glad I wouldn’t want to know
about any more being there than that
he said are you a religious man do you kneel down
in forest groves and let yourself ask for help
when you come to a waterfall
mist blowing against your face and arms
do you stop and ask for understanding at those moments
I said not yet but I intend to start today
he said I’m real sorry he said
I wish I had some other kind of news to give you
I said Amen and he said something else
I didn’t catch and not knowing what else to do
and not wanting him to have to repeat it
and me to have to fully digest it
I just looked at him
for a minute and he looked back it was then
I jumped up and shook hands with this man who’d just given me
something no one else on earth had ever given me

  • Blogger Post
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Digg
Subscribe

How Physicians Use the Internet to Enhance Patient Care

Saturday, November 21st, 2009

In a timely and coincidental response to my blog post from last week about how physicians are changing the way they were taught in medical school, Google Health has released research on how physicians utilize the internet in their practices.  In view of the volume of information that exist for physicians to have, it makes sense that the majority of them seek the internet as a resource.

If you are a physician, this information may be of interest to compare your personal practice to those of your peers.  If you are an organization that works with physicians, this information may help you reach out to physicians and/or help make sure physicians have what they need to enhance their practice of medicine.

Connecting with Physicians Online is the name of the research report.  The report was just released (November 2009).  The survey took place in May and June of 2009 and 411 physicians completed the survey.  Physicians had to be in practice for at least two years and 75% of their time needed to be in direct care in order to qualify for the survey.  Specialties included cardiology, endocrinology, psychiatry and primary care.

Here are some of the results:

  • 86% of physicians have used the internet to collect medical or drug information.
  • The internet exceeds other traditional methods of information resources (online CME courses, peer review journals, colleagues, books, etc.)
  • The office or practice setting is the most common place of internet engagement (92%) followed closely by the home (88%) and then by mobile applications (59%).
  • 58% access the internet more than once each day.
  • 70% spent three minutes or less researching a patient scenario.
  • 78% use two or more websites in their search.
  • Most physicians take action as a result of their research with 31% making a change in patient’s medication and another 30% initiate treatment and 32% conduct further testing.
  • 71% of physicians use a search engine versus a website to initiate their search.
  • 78% of physicians use 2 to five words for their searches.
  • Most physicians conduct one search, click on the top of the results page for the link they are looking for.
  • They find their results quickly with 52% reviewing only one search result.
  • Blogger Post
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Digg
Subscribe

Marcus Welby in the 21st Century

Saturday, November 14th, 2009

How a physician was taught in medical school impacts his or her approach to the delivery of care.  But, medical research has made such significant gains that some physicians may want to re-frame their training with new thinking.

At the New England Society for Healthcare Strategy conference titled, Clinical Care Innovation in an Era of Reform, Thomas Lee, M.D., an internist and cardiologist, and  network president for Partners Healthcare System and chief executive officer for Partners Community HealthCare, Inc, in Boston spoke about “Chaos and Organization in Healthcare.”  One of the many interesting comments he shared was that when he was in medical school, he was taught that as a physician treating patients, he should never consult a text book or any other kind of resource in front of the patient.  He was to appear knowledgeable and well informed and to rely on other resources would undermine this presentation.  Dr. Lee, a man in his mid-fifties, still marvels at this training and realizes it does not serve his approach today.

After hearing Dr. Lee, I read a New York Times article, “Making Healthcare Better.” The article is well worth a read but I was struck by the following paragraph as it evokes Dr. Lee’s very concern about his medical training:

We may still want our doctor to be like Marcus Welby, but our great fortune is that he cannot be. Medicine has made too much progress. The range of cures and treatments is too vast. Every year, medical journals publish hundreds of new findings that doctors are supposed to synthesize. Yet somehow, both doctors and patients have come to imagine that a physician can accomplish far more than any human being reasonably can. As a result, modern medicine is accomplishing far less than it reasonably should.

In view of Dr. Lee’s comments, I can see why there is tension for physicians in how they discuss health concerns with patients and how they choose to apply evidence-based medicine to their practice – if they choose to do so.  Because we are fortunate to live where the advantages of medical research are made available, we have much to be thankful for.  As history informs us, technology sometimes gets ahead of our ability to create new systems to best manage the advancements.  We might be in the midst of that scenario right now and will need to look to pioneering models like Intermountain Healthcare as they help move the art and science of medicine into a well-honed but incrementally different practice.


  • Blogger Post
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Digg
Subscribe